This week, we electric slide into 13 Going on 30, starring Jennifer Garner, Mark Ruffalo, and, as an awesome sassy-mean friend, Judy Greer! We discuss bad grade-school haircuts, old friends, wishing dust, and Andy Serkis' expressive eyes. We also develop the genius idea of a Paul Simon Broadway travelog/stage show, and we dive into our listener mail. And apparently every knows the Thriller dance!

This week we sled into 2005's Christmas classic Just Friends, starring Ryan Reynolds in a fat suit with a retainer! We can all relate to going home for the holidays and reverting right back to our high school selves. But somehow, Sarah uncovers a whole host of stories in which she was the high school heartbreaker. Do girls get friend-zoned? Can you age out of the friend zone? Do you call pants "trousers"? We cover these important questions and more this week!

Welcome to our first Christmas rom-com! We sleighride into Nancy Meyers' world of whimsy and fantasy on this week's episode. And we get two rom-coms in one with a double romance situation, tackling things like: is Jude Law hot? whose house is nicer? and who has the best acting chops in this film? We also play "Oh, Dern It," and Sarah eats while recording (again).

This week we are hot off the presses. Recorded last night and brought you to today! We tried to find a Thanksgiving rom-com, and we kind of did? This movie unleashes a lot of truth bombs about family and memory, but it loses itself in the romance area. Who is Leo Fish? How high was Robert Downey Jr. during the filming? Why couldn't (director) Jodie Foster stick to one theme? All good questions. All mostly unanswered. But it sure does nail the holidays.

This week, we leap into Leap Year, starring Amy Adams and Matthew Goode. Questions we ask: Are Leap Day proposals a thing? Would you spend $3500 on a suitcase? What would we grab if the house caught on fire? And, where is the romantic chemistry???

All these questions and more will be answered as we wind our way through this strange, awkward movie.

This week, we jump on the Netflix rom-com bandwagon and check out this cute high school story of a girl with lots of crushes and not a lot else. Lana Condor and Noah Centineo sizzle as unlikely partners in a situation only a rom-com could pull off. This movie really gets us to tap into our high school memories, for better or worse. We also discuss Asian yogurt drinks, Benny the Jet from Sandlot, and John Corbett!

Starring Mike Myers and Nancy Travis, this classic tale of love and murder may come in slightly late for Halloween, but who's counting? This week we discuss Justin being born 10 years too late for his perfect era, how we can find an artsy person to join our friend group, and whether a butcher shop is a safe place for a meet cute. Please, just watch this movie. It's so good!

Starring Christina Ricci, Bill Pullman, and Devon Sawa(!), Casper is our first kid rom-com, and it has a special place in Sarah's heart. But is it a rom-com? And who exactly is Lazarus? And why is Casper so round? All questions we hash out in this delightful, yet surprisingly dark, film. Devon Sawa!

Starring Kate Hudson and Matthew McConaughey, this adventure rom-com is sure to delight with its incredibly light-hearted tone and undeniable chemistry between the leads. Justin talks scuba diving, Sarah talks lake life, and we find true insight in the unlikeliest place. You'll be hard pressed to find a more fun, no-consequences movie.

Starring Merryl Streep and Amanda Seyfried, this movie remake is sure to make you want to dance right back into the 1970s. Colin Firth, Stellan Skarsgard, and Pierce Brosnan steal our hearts, but their vocals leave something to be desired. Justin and I discuss constellations, wearing overalls casually, and how live theater is always better. And we do some mean Cher impressions!

This week, we dive into You've Got Mail, starring Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan. This is a big-time heavy hitter, and we hope we did it justice. We discuss amicable break-ups, AIM relationships, cool away messages, and listener mail (not in that order). We both think Tom Hanks is the best, but does he have a weird thing with large bodies of water?

This week, we tackle Mannequin, starring Andrew McCarthy and Kim Cattrall. Our 80s-loving guru Natalie is the special guest! We discuss whether Kim Cattrall is Eqyptian, how inherently creepy mannequins are, and if it's okay to fall in love with an inanimate object. Sarah has a big reveal at the end, and Justin still can't do accents.

And now for something completely different! We go way back to cover the classic romcom Roman Holiday, starring Gregory Peck and Audrey Hepburn in her film debut.

We discuss the morality of getting a hot news story at all costs, Justin's understanding of female hairstyles, and if we were secret royalty. Do we have any business discussing this lovely and academy-award-winning movie? Probably not, but we tried our best.

This week, we cover Knocked Up, starring Katherine Heigl and Seth Rogen. Yes, another Katherine Heigl movie. We can't believe it either. All credit goes to our special guest Trivia Dave, who chose the movie because of his huge adolescent crush on Katherine Heigl. We also discuss how babies are made, pregnancy boobs, and why we don't see more birth scenes in movies. Justin finds a dryer sheet in his shirt, and Dave has a family of doctors.

Also, Sarah finally stops eating during recording!

This episode, we watch I Feel Pretty in the theater! It stars Amy Schumer and a bunch of other people. We discuss anxiety, body image, and Justin's inability to let go of old clothes. We worry about movies where the main character seems to have some sort of head trauma as a plot device. And we walked into the wrong theater! Just one more reason to watch movies at home.

This episode, we wade into My Best Friend's Wedding starring Julia Roberts and Dylan McDermott. But we all know that Rupert Everett steals the show as the best sidekick in rom-com history. Ever. And Cameron Diaz is excellent as the most lovable bride-to-be in an effed-up sitch.

Sarah has deep knowledge of this soundtrack, and this may have been where her fascination/attraction to mouth scars began. This one is a doozy, folks!

This episode, we discuss The Ugly Truth, starring Katherine Heigl and Gerard Butler. Sarah was drinking while watching this movie, so she enjoyed it far more than Justin. Still, we discuss the merits of vibrating underwear, sexy dancing, and scary, scary hot air balloons.